Cash vs Accrual Accounting, with a Worked Example
Cash basis and accrual basis are two answers to one question: which month does a sale or a cost belong to? The cash basis follows the bank account. The accrual basis follows the work. This page explains both, works through a real month of events on each basis, and shows the mistakes that trip people up most.
Try It Now, FreePractice It NowIn your browser, checked in a second. 3 exercises free, no sign-up.Every exercise in this lesson is open on your plan.
The Two Bases in One Sentence Each
Under the cash basis, revenue is recorded when the cash comes in and an expense is recorded when the cash goes out. Nothing else matters: not when the work was done, not when an invoice was sent, not when a bill arrived.
Under the accrual basis, revenue is recorded in the month the business earns it, which usually means the month it does the work or delivers the goods. An expense is recorded in the month the business uses what it pays for: the month the staff work, the month the advertising runs, the month the office is rented. When the cash moves is a separate question, handled through the balance sheet.
Over the life of a business both bases give the same total. They differ only in timing, and timing is what a monthly income statement is about.
Why the Accrual Basis Needs Extra Accounts
The cash basis needs very little: a list of money in and money out. The accrual basis has to keep track of the gaps between the cash and the work, and it does that with balance sheet accounts:
- Accounts receivable (an asset): work done and invoiced, not yet paid. Revenue is already counted; the cash is still owed to the business.
- Unearned revenue (a liability): a customer paid before the work was done. The cash is in the bank, but the revenue waits until the work is delivered. See the unearned revenue adjusting entry for the entries.
- Accounts payable and wages payable (liabilities): costs the business has used but not yet paid for. The expense is already counted; the cash goes out later. See accrued expenses.
- Prepaid expenses (an asset): the business paid before it used the thing, such as rent for several months at once. The expense is counted month by month as it is used up.
Those four accounts are exactly where the adjusting entries at month end come from. Adjusting entries are how a set of books moves from "what the cash did" to "what the business earned and used".
Two Questions for Every Event
You don't need to memorize a list of cases. For each event in the month, ask two questions:
- Did cash move this month? If cash came in from a customer, it is cash-basis revenue. If cash went out for a cost, it is a cash-basis expense.
- Was the work done, or the cost used up, this month? If the business did the work this month, it is accrual-basis revenue. If the business used the cost this month, it is an accrual-basis expense.
An event counts on each basis where the answer is yes. Some events are yes to both (a customer pays on the spot for today's job). Some are yes to one only (an invoice paid next month). And some are no to both, because they are not revenue or expenses at all: borrowing from the bank, or the owner putting money into the business. Cash comes in, but a loan has to be paid back, and the owner's money is owner's equity, so neither is revenue on either basis.
Worked Example: One Month at Juniper Landscaping
Here is a month generated the same way as the exercises in this lesson. Juniper Landscaping keeps its books for January, and these things happen:
- Collects $2,050 from customers for work done and invoiced last month.
- Does the work this month that a customer paid $800 for in advance last month.
- Finishes a job and is paid $1,800 in cash the same day.
- Pays $575 for repairs done last month, billed last month.
- The owner puts $5,000 of personal savings into the business.
- Pays $4,500 rent in advance for 3 months, starting this month.
- Finishes work for a customer and sends an invoice for $2,350. The customer will pay next month.
- Staff earn $2,175 of wages in the last week of the month. They will be paid next month.
- A customer pays $900 in advance for work to be done next month.
- Pays this month's $250 utilities bill.
Step 1: Read Each Event on Both Bases
| Event | Cash Basis | Accrual Basis |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Last month's invoices collected | Revenue 2,050 | None |
| 2. Work done on last month's prepayment | None | Revenue 800 |
| 3. Job done and paid the same day | Revenue 1,800 | Revenue 1,800 |
| 4. Last month's repair bill paid | Expense 575 | None |
| 5. Owner puts money in | None | None |
| 6. Rent paid ahead for 3 months | Expense 4,500 | Expense 1,500 |
| 7. Work invoiced, paid next month | None | Revenue 2,350 |
| 8. Wages earned, paid next month | None | Expense 2,175 |
| 9. Customer pays ahead for next month | Revenue 900 | None |
| 10. This month's utilities paid | Expense 250 | Expense 250 |
A few lines deserve a closer look. The $2,050 collected in event 1 was earned last month, so the accrual basis counted it then; collecting it now only turns a receivable into cash. Event 2 is the mirror image: the cash came last month, but the work, and so the revenue, is this month's. The rent in event 6 covers three months, so on the accrual basis January uses up only $4,500 ÷ 3 = $1,500; the other $3,000 stays on the balance sheet as prepaid rent.
Step 2: Add Up Each Column
| Cash Basis | Accrual Basis | Difference (Accrual − Cash) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 4,750 | 4,950 | 200 |
| Expenses | 5,325 | 3,925 | −1,400 |
| Net income | −575 | 1,025 | 1,600 |
Cash-basis revenue is $2,050 + $1,800 + $900 = $4,750. Accrual-basis revenue is $800 + $1,800 + $2,350 = $4,950. Cash-basis expenses are $575 + $4,500 + $250 = $5,325, and accrual-basis expenses are $1,500 + $2,175 + $250 = $3,925.
The same month shows a loss of $575 on the cash basis and a profit of $1,025 on the accrual basis. Neither is wrong. The cash basis says the bank balance fell from operations, mostly because three months of rent left in one go. The accrual basis says January's work earned more than the costs January used up.
Step 3: Explain the Difference
The difference in net income, $1,600, is made up of the events where the two columns disagree. These are the reconciling items. Starting from cash-basis net income:
- Add the $800 of work done on last month's prepayment and the $2,350 invoiced but unpaid (accrual revenue with no cash this month).
- Take away the $2,050 collected for last month and the $900 paid ahead by a customer (cash with no revenue this month).
- Add back the $575 paid for last month's repairs and the $3,000 of rent that belongs to later months (cash out with no expense this month).
- Take away the $2,175 of wages earned but not paid (an expense with no cash this month).
−$575 + $800 + $2,350 − $2,050 − $900 + $575 + $3,000 − $2,175 = $1,025, the accrual-basis net income. The revenue difference ($200) minus the expenses difference (−$1,400) gives the same $1,600. Checking the difference this way is a good habit: if the reconciling items don't add up, one event has been read the wrong way.
Common Mistakes
Counting a Customer Prepayment as Accrual Revenue
A customer paying for next month's work feels like a sale, and on the cash basis it is one. On the accrual basis nothing has been earned yet: the business owes the work or a refund. The cash is unearned revenue, a liability, until the work is done.
Counting Last Month's Collections as This Month's Accrual Revenue
When customers pay last month's invoices, the cash is new but the revenue is not. The accrual basis recorded it last month, when the work was done. Counting it again would record the same sale twice.
Counting an Unpaid Invoice as Cash Revenue
An invoice is a request for cash, not cash. The cash basis waits until the customer actually pays.
Leaving Unpaid Costs Out of Accrual Expenses
Wages your staff earned this month and bills for services used this month are this month's expenses on the accrual basis, even though the cash goes out later. Leaving them out makes the month look more profitable than it was. The accrued revenue and accrued expense entries exist to catch exactly these items at month end.
Expensing a Multi-Month Prepayment All at Once
Rent, insurance or a subscription paid for several months is a cash-basis expense in full when it is paid. On the accrual basis, only the share used this month is an expense; the rest is a prepaid asset that is used up month by month.
Treating Loans and Owner Money as Revenue
Cash in is not the same as revenue, even on the cash basis. A bank loan is a liability and the owner's money is owner's equity. Neither appears on the income statement under either basis.
Getting the Sign of the Difference Wrong
If a question asks for accrual minus cash, start from the accrual figure. A negative difference simply means the cash basis shows the bigger amount on that line.
Which basis do financial statements use?
Accounting standards for general-purpose financial statements are built on the accrual basis, because it matches revenue with the costs of earning it in the same period. That is why an income statement prepared from adjusted books shows accrual figures. Many very small businesses keep simple cash records day to day, and some bookkeepers keep the books on the cash basis during the month and post adjusting entries at month end to bring them to the accrual basis.
Which basis a business may use for tax or for a lender depends on local rules and its circumstances, a question for a qualified adviser. This page covers the bookkeeping skill: the right figures on either basis, and the difference explained.
How to Practice
The exercises in this lesson give you a fresh month of events every time. The first asks for revenue only; the next adds expenses and net income; the third adds multi-month prepayments and the difference on each line; the last asks for each event's effect on net income, the reconciliation from Step 3. Feedback names the mistake when your figures match one of the common ones above.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between cash and accrual accounting?
Timing. The cash basis records revenue and expenses when cash moves. The accrual basis records revenue when it is earned and expenses when the business uses what it pays for, whenever the cash moves.
Is a customer deposit revenue?
On the cash basis, yes, when the cash arrives. On the accrual basis, no: it is unearned revenue, a liability, until the work is done. It becomes revenue in the month the business delivers.
Is borrowing money revenue on the cash basis?
No. The cash basis counts cash from customers for goods or services. A loan has to be paid back, so it is a liability on either basis. Repaying the loan's principal is not an expense either.
How do I reconcile cash-basis and accrual-basis net income?
Start from one figure and adjust for each event the two bases treat differently: invoices not yet paid, collections for earlier months, customer prepayments, unpaid costs, payments for earlier months' costs and the unused part of prepaid expenses. The adjustments add up to the difference.